Album Review: Neil Young’s Vulnerable ‘Storytone’ Sings About Love -- and Saving the Environment

Album Review

Few singers play vulnerability better than Neil Young. It's the most affecting trait of this collection of a dozen songs, presented in two separate versions: one set gussied up in formal wear, and the other kicking back in shorts and T-shirts on the back porch. Not that the section recorded with a 92-piece orchestra choir and a bluesy big band doesn't have its charms, but the solo recordings have an intimacy and power that play to Young's well-known strengths as a songwriter, guitarist and world-weary vocalist.

Neil Young Announces Release Date, Tracklist for ‘Storytone'

Young, 68, recorded the tunes, mostly on piano, for the solo section. These are not demos: The recordings are polished and his vocals finessed with modulation to smartly complement the accompaniment. The songs reveal the undiminished spark in Young's songwriting. His subjects -- new love, the environment and Chicago blues (with plenty of references to cars) -- fit the news of his recent life activities (divorce, new romance, alternative fuel/anti-fracking activism). "I'm Glad I Found You" has all the hallmarks of a classic wedding tune. The stripped-down album is trademark Young in many ways, gracefully fitting within a framework that recalls his quieter moments of After the Gold Rush, Tonight's the Night and the underappreciated Sleeps With Angels.

Neil Young Readies Pono Store, Says Partnerships With Lincoln, Tesla in Works

Heavyweight recording engineer Al Schmitt and arranger-orchestrators Michael Bearden and Chris Walden inflated these songs to an extreme degree for the beefier version -- Young's previous orchestral work, on 1972's Harvest and big-band exercise This Note's For You, are child's play compared with Storytone. But tracks like "Glimmer," a fine love song, is a perfect example of how ill-fitting this approach can be: Young's scratchy vocal fails to complement its exquisitely cinematic orchestration until the final two lines show a fleshed-out poignancy. It's the same, too, with his blues performances, where all the power is in the back -- a vibrant horn section echoes Count Basie's Atomic Band -- but the frontman is unable to pull his weight. His talk-singing is far more convincing when the accompaniment is a sole electric guitar.

Hear Neil Young Protest Fracking & Corporate America in ‘Who's Gonna Stand Up'

At times, though, Young and his many collaborators do gel. "Tumbleweed," with melodic hooks that recall Buddy Holly's classic "Every Day," is sweet and inviting. "When I Watch You Sleeping" and "All Those Dreams" are a sublime marriage of his gentle 1990s acoustic work and the orchestral accompaniments of '60s country-pop.

This article will appear in the Nov. 15 issue of Billboard.