Movie Review: Backstreet Boys Doc 'Show 'Em What You're Made Of' Depicts Boy Band's Complicated Journey

Backstreet Boys
Review
4

The life span of a boy band can often seem predetermined. As the boys mature into men and their teen audience ages out, two paths emerge: either break up and move on, or embrace their fate as a nostalgia act.

Exclusive: Backstreet Boys Discuss What's Next For Them in Documentary Clip

For Backstreet Boys, the highs were skyscraping: They moved tens of millions of albums worldwide, sold out arenas and had an embarrassment of chart-topping hits. But the documentary Show 'Em What You're Made Of, an all-access pass to the quintet's life during the past two years, focuses less on its planet-conquering success than it does on what happened when it faded. It's a naked examination of how little fame matters when it fails to yield anything lasting, be it personal wealth or fulfillment, skillfully humanizing a group whose celebrity outshined the players within it.

In the doc, the members (Brian Littrell, Nick Carter, Howie Dorough, Kevin Richardson and A.J. McLean) unflinchingly come to terms with a past that haunts them. Emotions bubble to the surface when they return to their childhood homes -- most weep while reflecting on lives left behind -- and soon turn vindictive as they rehash how the group's creator, Lou Pearlman, who's currently incarcerated for running a Ponzi scheme, financially betrayed them.

Backstreet Boys Cancel Israel Concerts Amid Hostilities

But it's when the Boys contemplate the future that the film really compels. As they grapple with Littrell's vocal detrition in the face of a hoped-for comeback, tensions mount; during a meeting about a new LP, Carter erupts, blaming him for failures that are yet to happen. It's the ugly side of a group whose pretty looks used to be a selling point, and it has come to light in this surprisingly fascinating film.

This story will appear in the Feb. 14 issue of Billboard.