The Who's 'Quadrophenia' At 40: Classic Track-By-Track Review
The Who's second rock opera, "Quadrophenia," released 40 years ago in October 1973, was Pete Townshend's homage to an earlier moment in British youth culture. Composed entirely by Townshend, the 17-song opus told the story of Jimmy, a member of the Mods -- a U.K. subculture -- by chronicling his dissatisfaction with life, work, love, home, and family. But it also functioned as an ode to teenage angst and counterculture rebellion, as well as a criticism of the British class, economic and educational systems. And, finally "Quadrophenia" told the story of the Who's first fans in the band's earliest days, playing pubs and clubs in and around London in the '60s.
Filled with performances packed with life and depth and personality, "Quadrophenia" is 90 minutes of the Who at its very best. "The reason why the album is so important to me is that I think it's the Who's last great album, really," Townshend told Billboard in 2011. But what makes it great isn't the production or the sound effects but the bones of the songs: the music and the lyrics as well as the individual guitar, bass, vocal, and drum performances from Townshend, John Entwistle, Roger Daltrey and Keith Moon, respectively.
The old adage "write what you know" is what makes the narrative work so well: Townshend (and the rest of the Who) knew and cared about kids just like Jimmy. You don't need to be clued into the history of the Mods and Rockers to enjoy the album because at its core, "Quadrophenia," which peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard 200, is just about teenage confusion, conflict and frustration.
1. "I Am The Sea"
"I Am The Sea" is a collection of sounds and melodies. Staying true to the concept that this album was truly an opera and not a random collection of songs, Townshend developed musical motifs which recur throughout the album. The crashing of waves, the sounds of seagulls and of raindrops falling are intermixed with Roger Daltrey's voice referencing lyrics and melodies from the band members' individual themes -- "Love, Reign O'Er Me" (Pete's theme), "Helpless Dancer" (Roger's theme), "Bell Boy" (Keith's theme) and "Doctor Jimmy" (John's theme). At the end, the other sounds cut out as Daltrey's voice comes to the forefront abruptly asking the first question of the album: "Can you see the real me? Can ya?"
2. "The Real Me"
Daltrey's passionate vocals, John Entwistle's surprisingly melodic bass line, trademark Townshend power chords, Keith Moon's nimble, non-stop drumming--all of this with a horn arrangement on the choruses -- bring energy and emphasis to the lyrics which reference the album's essential question: Jimmy doesn't know who he is. He struggles with how everyone sees him: his friends, his mother, his father, his employers, the Mods--and finally, himself.
Like "I Am The Sea," this is another instrumental number which brings in the leitmotifs again. Dominated by keyboard and synthesizer, “Quadrophenia” has an orchestral and occasionally martial feel to the arrangement and melody. Although a very solid track, it can feel like a roadblock getting in the way with the flow of the story, which had just gotten underway.
4. "Cut My Hair"
With Townshend on lead vocal, "Cut My Hair" finds Jimmy struggling with adulthood and fitting in at work, home and with the Mods. “Why do I have to move with the crowd/The kids at home don't notice I'm around/I have to work myself to death just to fit in,” sings Pete.
The sounds of a simulated BBC News report about the Mods, along with a whistling tea kettle ends the track, telling us that Jimmy's listening to this at home in the kitchen. After trying and failing to make movies from previous albums, Townshend deliberately fashioned a quasi-soundtrack this time by the use of the sound effects and other transitions.
5. "The Punk and the Godfather"
One of the record's iconic moments, the song opens with clanging power chords, perfectly interspersed percussion, and majestic vocals. This track is trademark Who, period. The lyrics tell the story of Jimmy going to see one of his favorite bands in concert and being rebuffed after seeking them out after the show. This causes a crisis of faith as now even rock 'n' roll has betrayed him. "No surprise I told lies/I'm the punk in the gutter," Daltrey sings as the Godfather, before reprising a bit of "My Generation,” in case we didn't get the point.
Entwistle's powerful, melodic bass should not be underestimated here; it's like a second vocal line and provides more melody than the guitar does. Townshend functions as rhythm guitar to Entwistle here.
In the final verse, Townshend takes the lead vocal. This lyric is one of his best on the conflict between star and audience: "And yet I live your future out/By pounding stages like a clown." It's an unintentional secondary theme on the album, but a subject he writes about better than anyone else.
6. "I'm One"
"Every year is the same, and I feel it again / I'm a loser, no chance to win," sings Townshend alone, accompanied by acoustic guitar, as Jimmy thinks through his disappointment after seeing the Godfather. He finds comfort in the fact that while there are no real answers, but takes solace in--"I'm one." The melody is almost country-flavored on the emphatically sung chorus, with touches of electric guitar interspersed with the acoustic underlay, Entwistle's bass once again holding everything down quietly underneath. The song remains a Townshend tour-de-force live.
7. "The Dirty Jobs"
The melody is anchored by keyboards, Daltrey's vocals are highly processed, while lyrically the song lacks Townshend's usual subtlety as he portrays Jimmy's life after he goes to work as a garbage man (after rejecting what he sees as the emptiness of working in an office).
8. "Helpless Dancer (Roger's Theme)"
This stripped-down track is a departure from the garden-variety rock 'n' roll on the rest of the album. Opening with french horn (which would be played live onstage by Entwistle) and the dramatic piano chords which underpin the rest of the song, Roger Daltrey dramatically recites the lyrics as the mixing has each line come out of a different speaker for further deliberate effect. The melody is highlighted with acoustic flourishes from Townshend about halfway through. The track is meant to summarize Jimmy's disillusionment with class and society, and his anger and bitterness are starting to bubble to the surface: "You realize that all along/something in us is going wrong/You stop dancing."
9. "Is It In My Head"
A straight-ahead power ballad, Townshend asserts in the liner notes that "Is It In My Head" is about Jimmy's self-doubt. However, this is likely the most autobiographical number on the album ("Statements to a stranger/Asking for directions/Turn from being help to being questions") and that's probably why it's Daltrey's least convincing performance. Townshend's original demo (available on the 2011 deluxe reissue) feels truer to the emotional arc at this point of the story.
10. "I've Had Enough"
This is the moment where Jimmy gives up, stops trying to maintain his place in society or within the Mods. A remarkably restrained Keith Moon rolls us into the track, accented with guitar chords and keyboards, before exploding into the end of the verse. Townshend sings the middle of the refrain, which switches melody to a straight-ahead R&B beat, in tribute to the Mods which the verse directly references. The "Love, Reign O'er Me" refrain floats in yet again before the recitation of all of the things Jimmy is tired of, underscored by (of all things) a banjo: "I'm finished with the fashions/And acting like I'm tough/I'm bored with hate and passion/I've had enough of trying to love…"
That last word is screamed with every possible ounce of Daltrey power-scream venom before crashing into a halt, likely symbolizing Jimmy accidentally (or deliberately) smashing his prized Vespa. He then decides to head to Brighton, scene of previous outings with the Mods, and try to recapture some of what he used to feel like. To get there, he takes a train.
"Quadrophenia"'s best-known song opens with the echoes of announcements and the clack of a British Railway train door closing, before the gentle chords and Townshend's vocals intoning, "Why should I care?" Then, you have two seconds to catch your breath before the song cascades down before throttling straight ahead, like a roller coaster. The horns are back again in all their glory, underscoring the refrain, along with ringing piano chords highlighting it all. Daltrey is relaxed, ebullient, having fun with Townshend's brilliant wordplay.
Jimmy heads to Brighton high on speed, stuck between two stodgy businessmen who do not approve of his existence, let alone his presence. The lyrics are a scattershot recollection of everything Jimmy's experienced over the past weeks, months, years, capped by one of Townshend's best lyrics on rock stardom: "Sadly ecstatic/That their heroes are news."
12. "Sea and Sand"
Once in Brighton, Jimmy comes down from the amphetamine rush only to discover a quiet, sleepy seaside town, far from the glorious stomping ground that he remembers. He reminiscences about his parents, his ex-girlfriend, and the Mods. A rougher version of their refrain from "I've Had Enough," sung by Townshend, comes in and out of the song, amping up the pace each time to spread its energy throughout. Daltrey's vocals are restrained, but only just. Townshend's various guitar tracks are absolutely masterful, both the subtle rhythm track and the lead amps up and down in intensity throughout the song. The first single from the Who's original incarnation--The High Numbers' "I'm The Face”--gets referenced at the end of the track.
"Drowned" is a rocking ballad where the music is at odds with the desperation and pessimism expressed in the lyrics. Jimmy's given up and doesn't know what to do or where to go next. "Drowned" also became a staple of Townshend's solo outings, and transformed into an compelling acoustic number, given a more intense reading vocally by Pete.
14. "Bell Boy (Keith's Theme)"
"Bell Boy" is a straight-ahead rocker, relating a direct lyrical account of Jimmy discovering that the head Mod--the "Ace Face," everybody hero-- is working as a bellboy in the Grand Hotel, which the Mods had previously invaded. Live, this song was performed by both Roger Daltrey with rare lead vocals from Keith Moon, which were not always entirely successful. The 2012 revival of the album had the band cutting to a taped version of Moon for his verses, which felt perhaps a little too Hologram Keith and less like the tribute it was clearly intended to be.
15. "Dr. Jimmy"
"Dr. Jimmy" is a thunderous, complex composition featuring horns and strings (along with every element of the rest of the Who's secret sauce), anchored by one of Daltrey's strongest vocal performances on the record. (That's a lot considering what's still to come.) Keith Moon is also an unstoppable force on this song. Jimmy has reached breaking point and all of his emotions are coming to the forefront, at exactly the same time. The songwriting, the vocals and the performance absolutely match the passion in the lyrics. "Is it me? For a moment," Daltrey returns to, again and again. Because that's the question Jimmy has come to Brighton to answer.
16. "The Rock"
The last instrumental opens with the sounds waves and an outboard motor. The leitmotifs reappear in various forms as Jimmy takes the boat he's commandeered out to a rock in the middle of the ocean, where he sits and watches the waves and waits and hopes and thinks. The instrumentation mimics the sound and motion of the waves in different strengths as well as mirroring Jimmy's surge of emotions. To the listener, things don't seem like they're going to end well for Jimmy. Then, there’s a screech of strings, and then an explosion of rain, and thunder, and then more rain.
17. "Love, Reign O'er Me"
As the rain continues, three expansive, deliberate piano chords introduce the song, before the tympani and the bass notes on the piano and the cymbal crash cascade up. No matter what you think of the rest of the "Quadrophenia" story, there is no doubt that the ending is about catharsis and triumph. It's the song that most perfectly captures the dynamic of the band, that Pete writes songs for Roger to sing. It is Daltrey's defining moment, more than anything on "Tommy," more than "Won't Get Fooled Again." He ratchets up the emotion to 11, brings it back down to tell the rest of the story…and then takes it back up there one more time. Townshend's guitar work is cool, understated, but just as emotive and vital to the atmosphere.
The second-to-last power scream is almost as heart-wrenching as the final one, the one that closes the record, as Moon and Entwistle and then Townshend crash down (in the case of Keith Moon, quite literally wrecking his drumkit in the studio) and then explode into a glorious, ear-splitting conclusion to end the record, and the story. It is a fitting anthem for a crisis of faith.