Adam Lambert Reminisces About His First Post-'Idol' Single (and Why He's Happy Pink Rejected It)

american idol pkg ONLY
Zoey Grossman
Adam Lambert photographed in 2015.

He came in second in season eight, but Adam Lambert, 34, scored a radio hit on his first try. “Whataya Want From Me,” from his 2009 RCA debut, For Your Entertainment, peaked at No. 10 on the Billboard Hot 100. No surprise here: He got a little help from Sweden.

‘American Idol’ Special FeatureAdam Lambert on First Post-‘Idol’ Single |‚Äč Paula Abdul on Simon Cowell | Ryan Seacrest on Eliminating Contestants Constantine Maroulis on Seducing the Camera | Harry Connick Jr. on Being a Judge | A Tribute to ‘Idol’ | Lee DeWyze on Singing ‘Hallelujah’ | Allison Iraheta on Her ‘Idol’ Gig |Todrick Hall on Post-‘Idol’ Fame | Inside ‘Idol’: Show Creator Simon Fuller and More

Cast A Wide Net
“[A&R executive] Ashley Newton was my hero at the label. He and Iain Pirie at 19 Entertainment helped me put together a list of people that I wanted to work with. Max Martin and Dr. Luke were on that list, pop’s hottest guys at that time. I did some of my own writing but it was such a fast process that we needed songs, and we got songs from Lady Gaga, Matt Bellamy of Muse, Rivers Cuomo and Linda Perry. Now that I look back, it’s like, ‘Damn! They really showed up for me.’ ”

Hire Max Martin
“Max knew exactly what he wanted in the studio. He was so chill, I immediately got comfortable. He helped me achieve a really emotional, intimate vocal.”

Don't Fear The Reject
Pink wrote ‘Whataya Want From Me’ and then decided she didn’t want to put it on her album for personal reasons. I think she was quoted  saying she didn’t want to go into the sentiment of the song. I did! A great song is a song that means different things to different people. It was a really honest sentiment and a great hook.”

Stir Up Some Controversy
“My concept for the album was modern-day glam rock. I was pushing for [the title track] to be the first single, but after performing it on the American Music Awards [controversy erupted over a crotch grab and a kiss], RCA decided to release ‘Whataya Want From Me’ instead. To me, the AMAs was really tame. But as an artist. I think you want conversation. You want people to talk about what you’re doing.”

-- Reporting by Fred Bronson

A version of this story originally appeared in the March 25 issue of Billboard.