The ruling comes after a lengthy -- and at times, thorny -- dispute between Garrix (real name Martijn Garritsen) and the label, which counts heavy-hitters like Tiësto and Afrojack among its alums.
Garrix first split with Spinnin' in 2015, citing a disagreement over ownership rights of his music. He later filed a lawsuit against former manager Eelko van Kooten, who Garrix claims provided "false and misleading information" that led him to sign with the label and management company back in 2012, renewing his contract in 2013. Garrix also claimed that van Kooten's involvement in both Spinnin' and MusicAllStars represented a conflict of interest, and that van Kooten intentionally misled Garrix into thinking he had no option but to sign a combination contract.
But the legal proceedings have yet to reach the finish line. Dutch online newspaper NU.nl reports that Garrix is demanding €3.7 million (roughly $4.4 million) from Spinnin' and €650,000 (nearly $780,000) from MusicAllStars, which in turn want Garrix to fork over €6.4 million ($7.7 million). Garrix's team has told Billboard, "All of Spinnin/MAS' claims have been rejected by the court. The only remaining question is the amount to be repaid by Spinnin/MAS to Martijn."
Meanwhile, Warner Music recently purchased Spinnin' Records and its music publishing and artist management divisions, and van Kooten exited the company. The label's current roster includes Bob Sinclar, EDX, Fedde Le Grand and Kris Kross Amsterdam, among others.