The registrations are reviewed, including past ticket purchase history and even social media accounts, with an eye toward determining whether they're more likely to be event attendees. Those accepted get unique codes that they can use when they go to buy tickets on the sale date.
The premise is that by vetting registrants, it's more likely that actual fans would be the ones getting the first crack at hot tickets, instead of brokers and re-sellers.
"That makes me feel better," said Elster, 66, a videographer who lives in Margate, Florida. "That makes me feel like I have a chance maybe, more of a chance than usual."
Verified Fan has been used for concert sales for artists such as Ed Sheeran and Harry Styles, and is now showing up for Broadway sales. Springsteen on Broadway, running from Oct. 3 to Nov. 26, is using the system, as is another show expected to be a hot prospect, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, opening next spring.
The producers of the immensely popular Hamilton announced Tuesday that a new block of tickets for the show would go on sale through Verified Fan. That show has been the subject of a huge re-sale market, with tickets going for hundreds of dollars if not more than the face values.
Premium seats for Hamilton run as high as $849, with prices on the secondary ticket markets more than double that amount. While "Hamilton" has put aside a few digital lottery seats for $10, the average ticket last week went for $282.65.
Those kinds of prices make Ayodele Williams, 44, of Philadelphia, outraged. She and her sister were in New York last week to see a performance of Hamilton, and they had tickets they consider themselves lucky to have snagged at face value last fall.
"It's become so expensive and rigged," Williams said. "If you have some kind of system or algorithm that allows you to buy all these tickets, you're going to get them and then all you're doing is re-selling. You're not doing it for the love of the show really. You're doing it for the love of the money."
David Marcus, executive vice president for Ticketmaster, said that was the point of the registration system: to give fans a better experience.
"It's intended to make the initial distribution fairer," he said, to fight against a system where brokers are the first ones out of the gate for tickets. Re-sale has a role, he said, but it shouldn't be the oversize one it's playing.
He said so far the program has been working. Of the more than a million tickets distributed through Verified Fan since it began beta testing late last year, less than 5 percent have gone onto the secondary re-sale market.