'Empire' Beats 'Gangsta Pimp's' $10M Copyright Suit

Terrence Howard on Empire
Chuck Hodes/FOX

Terrence Howard as Lucious Lyon in the "Past is Prologue" season finale episode of Empire on May 18, 2016 on FOX. 

Empire didn't copy self-described "gangsta pimp" Ron Newt's life story Bigger Than Big, according to a California federal judge.

Newt sued Lee Daniels, Terrence Howard and 20th Century Fox for $1 billion in April 2015, claiming they stole his story years after he spent three hours telling it to Howard. Shortly thereafter, he hired attorney Charles Coate and filed an amended complaint, dialing back his damages to $10 million. Fox fired back in October saying Empire is akin to a modern-day King Lear and not based on Newt's "crudely written, violent, regretful" work.

Fox Looks to End $10 Million Lawsuit Alleging 'Empire' Ripped Off Man's Life Story

U.S. District Court judge Consuelo Marshall dismissed the suit on Wednesday, finding there is no substantial similarity with respect to plot and the theme of "a bad person turning his life around" is unprotectable.

To prevail, Newt would have had to prove he owned a valid copyright to Bigger Than Big, that the defendants had access to it and that Empire is substantially similar to it. Fox doesn't contest that Newt owns the book, screenplay and DVD of Bigger Than Big, or that defendants had access to it, so Marshall only considered the issue of substantial similarity.

"Although the parties’ works each follow an African American man who was involved in drug dealing and has sons pursuing a music career, Plaintiff’s works and Empire are not substantially similar as to plot," writes Marshall.

In Marshall's opinion, two-thirds of Newt's documentary centers on his work as a pimp in San Francisco, while the remaining third focuses on his sons' group the Newtrons, and his book and screenplay primarily focus on "the violence, sex, drugs and crime" surrounding Newt's life as a drug lord. Meanwhile, Marshall found Empire focuses on "the power struggle amongst the Lyons — an African American family in the music business."

Sean Penn Wins Apology from 'Empire' Creator Lee Daniels in Defamation Settlement

Further, Marshall found the common plot elements of "pursuing dreams of music careers" and "[t]he concept of a bad person spending time in prison" are unprotectable and there is "virtually no overlap in dialogue."

Other things Marshall finds unprotectable: the fact that the sons the works wear sunglasses and gold chains, similarity in age between the male leads, that some of the sons sing.

"Plaintiff has demonstrated, at most, random similarities between the works which does not constitute substantial similarity," Marshall writes. 

Marshall also dismissed Newt's breach of implied-in-fact contract claim without prejudice. As it is a state law claim, if Newt takes another shot at that complaint it would be in L.A. County Superior Court. 

Coate has not yet responded to a request for comment.

Marshall's full opinion is at THR.com.

THE BILLBOARD BIZ
SUBSCRIBER EXPERIENCE

The Biz premium subscriber content has moved to Billboard.com/business.


To simplify subscriber access, we have temporarily disabled the password requirement.