Broadway Musical 'Amazing Grace' to Close

Joan Marcus
Laiona Michelle and Rachael Ferrera in "Amazing Grace." 

No prayers can save the new musical Amazing Grace on Broadway - it's closing.

The musical, with music and lyrics by Christopher Smith and a book by Smith and Arthur Giron, centers on John Newton, an 18th-century slave trader whose spiritual awakening led him to write the hymn.

Broadway Box Office: ‘Hedwig' Goes Out With a Bang

The show, starring Tony Award nominee Josh Young and Tony winner Chuck Cooper, will close Oct. 25 after 24 previews and 114 regular performances.

In a statement, producer Carolyn Rossi Copeland said her team is "incredibly disappointed" in the show's performance at the box office" and promised a national tour.

'American Psycho' Musical Heading to Broadway

The show was poorly received by critics and struggled to fill even half the Nederlander Theatre. It rarely pulled in more than 30 percent of its $1 million weekly box office potential.