On Wednesday (May 5), The Kelly Clarkson Show shared a digital exclusive of the host playing a game where she had to pick between her favorite '90s artists -- and it came down to the wire when she had to choose between Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey.
Before chatting with the cast of the new Peacock series Girls5eva, starring Sara Bareilles, Renée Elise Goldsberry, Busy Philipps and Paula Pell as a reuniting '90s girl group, Clarkson paid homage to the era with a game of Who Would You Rather: '90s Music Edition. Clarkson said she'd rather play beer pong with Cher over Madonna, be in a group text with Destiny's Child over Spice Girls, trust *NSYNC over Hanson to run her social media, and when it came to who she would trust between Brandy and Monica to keep her biggest secret, the choice was Brandy.
"I've met Brandy and I'd trust 'Sittin' Up in My Room,' anybody who could write that jam. I would trust her with anything," she said, while tossing in a mention of her titular role in the 1997 musical TV film Cinderella. "'Member when she and Whitney did Cinderella?"