For One Direction, A Clean Break From Zayn Was the Right Move

Jeff Daly/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images
Harry Styles, Liam Payne, Louis Tomlinson, and Niall Horan of the band One Direction appear on the "Today" show from Universal Orlando Resort on Monday, November 17, 2014.

Zayn Malik's departure marks a sad development -- but watching the group's problems fester would have been sadder.

"After five incredible years Zayn Malik has decided to leave One Direction," a post on the boy band's Facebook page began on Wednesday (Mar. 25). Well, there's no gray area in that statement. The news that Zayn is leaving One Direction immediately impacted fans worldwide, ending an era for one of the most successful pop groups of all time. Billboard's top artist of 2014 -- a stadium-headlining group, and one that set a record by sending its first four albums to No. 1 -- has lost a founding member in the (relative) prime of its career. Even if you're not one of the teen girls running out of geometry class to sob, it's hard to shrug off that pain, or dismiss how huge of a story this is in the music world.

And while that opening line to One Direction's statement was the note's most important, the following sentence is nearly as crucial. "Niall, Harry, Liam and Louis will continue as a four-piece and look forward to the forthcoming concerts of their world tour and recording their fifth album, due to be released later this year," the group writes. It's a sad day for One Direction, but today is not the end of One Direction. And in many ways, today's clean split from Zayn Malik -- as difficult as it may have been for the band and its team to pull that trigger -- was probably the right move at the right time for the group, who have smartly assured fans that a future for 1D exists.



The sudden departure of Zayn Malik from the group's international tour in support of Four occurred less than a week ago, when One Direction announced that the troubled member was headed back to the U.K. and missing two shows due to "stress." Speculation immediately grabbed hold of the announcement's neck, and questions as to what was really troubling Zayn, when he would be back on the tour and if he would ever be back on the tour were gasped out for days. On Monday, a rep for the group still was not able to relay a timetable for Zayn's return. As of now, we still don't know how quickly his exit was decided upon, or which camp -- Zayn, or One Direction -- made that final call (the group's label declined further comment to Billboard on Wednesday afternoon). We do know, however, that the move was decisively absolute, and necessarily so.

Zayn Malik Leaves One Direction, But Don't Expect a Justin Timberlake-Style Break Out

Zayn's exit from One Direction is painful because it means something has ended, but it would have been vastly more painful to approach the next few months with a sense of unsteadiness. If Zayn had not rejoined the world tour before Apr. 4, when the band begins a two-month break that leads into the European leg of their latest live run, that would have led to an entire season of the vague uncertainty that fans have experienced in the past week. The focus would not have been on the band's new singles or live performances, but on the behind-the-scenes drama that had sidelined Zayn in the middle of an album cycle.

And if Zayn had rushed back on tour after missing a handful of shows, then what? Questions of his commitment and well-being would have persisted, his involvement on One Direction's next album would need to be underlined, and every movement of Zayn's would have been analyzed after such a striking outburst of unhappiness. It's hard to imagine a scenario in which Zayn could have avoided becoming a sideshow with regard to the group's future, in the middle of a period in which One Direction is expected to entertain millions of ticket buyers and produce another fourth-quarter album.

Zayn Leaves 1D: 10 Must-See Twitter Reactions | Zayn Malik Explains One Direction Exit

Now, Zayn is gone, and One Direction can move on. By writing that "Niall, Harry, Liam and Louis will continue as a four-piece," One Direction has ensured that Zayn will not be replaced, that the One Direction machine will not slow down, and that concertgoers will still be receiving a 2015 stadium experience, if a slightly different stadium experience than they expected a week ago. The news that One Direction's fifth album is due out later this year is also quietly gigantic: sure, 1D has released four albums in the past four years, but that was far from a guarantee that a fifth one was on its way, from a group that has tirelessly delighted fans for a half-decade without any sort of extended break. The fact that Zayn's departure from One Direction clearly does not equal the end of One Direction -- when, let's face it, it very well could have been -- should mean something to longtime fans. Just because 1D will no longer have its "classic" lineup does not mean that dazzling shows and easily digestible pop tunes are not the group's immediate future.

The first few shows without Zayn on board will continue to feel strange, as will counting four members instead of five on their next album cover. Perhaps Zayn will rejoin One Direction at some point -- his future involvement will be a point of conjecture for as long as 1D forges on as a four-piece. Yet that sort of speculation is undoubtedly preferable to wondering whether or not Zayn is dropping out, and if so, whether it would destroy the band. For now, One Direction remains a united front with a clear future -- and for now, that's enough.

Zayn Malik Leaves One Direction