On the all-format Billboard 200, Fetch the Bolt Cutters enters at No. 4, marking her third top 10, following The Idler Wheel... (No. 3) and Extraordinary Machine (No. 7, October 2005). Apple has also reached the ranking with When the Pawn… (No. 13, 1999) and her debut LP Tidal (No. 15, 1997).
Concurrently, five tracks from Fetch the Bolt Cutters debut on the Hot Rock Songs chart, led by "I Want You to Love Me" at No. 10 thanks to 2.1 million U.S. streams and 1,000 downloads sold. "Shameika," which starts at No. 15 (1.5 million streams), gets a boost from radio airplay, as it's bubbling under the Adult Alternative Songs list; it nabbed 386,000 audience impressions on rock radio in the tracking week ending April 26.
Should "Shameika" reach an airplay chart, it would mark Apple's first such appearance in 20 years, since "Fast as You Can" hit Nos. 8, 20 and 29 on Adult Alternative Songs, Alternative Songs and Adult Pop Songs, respectively, in late 1999/early 2000.