Billboard requires a JavaScript enabled browser to get the full experience

Eminem, Apple Headed For Trial As Talks Break Down

by Jonathan Stempel, Reuters  |   September 24, 2009 9:39 EDT

Eminem and Apple Inc have failed to settle a lawsuit over whether the rapper's songs can be downloaded on the iTunes music service, paving the way for a federal trial to begin on Thursday.

Eight Mile Style LLC, Eminem's music publisher, had accused iPod maker Apple in a 2007 lawsuit of having used 93 songs in a downloadable format on iTunes without permission.

It also sued Aftermath Records, saying it had no right to approve digital downloads, despite having control of Eminem recordings under agreements entered into in 1998 and 2003.

The non-jury trial is expected to be held in federal court in Detroit, Eminem's hometown.

Last-ditch talks held on Wednesday before a federal magistrate judge in Ann Arbor, Michigan, broke down after three different mediators had previously been unable to broker a settlement.

"The case did not settle today and we are expecting to start trial first thing tomorrow morning," Howard Hertz, a lawyer for Eight Mile Style, said on Wednesday.

Apple spokeswoman Susan Lundgren said the Cupertino, California company does not discuss pending litigation. Lawyers for Apple and Aftermath could not immediately be reached.

Another plaintiff in the case is Martin Affiliated LLC, which has a portion of Eight Mile Style's interests.

It is not clear how much money the plaintiffs are trying to recover. They contend Apple wrongfully gained $2.58 million from iTunes downloads, including $466,916 from "Lose Yourself," a hit from Eminem's 2002 film "8 Mile."

The plaintiffs also want part of what they say is Apple's $16 million of profit from iPod sales that could be attributed to the 93 songs, as well as $4.03 million from Aftermath.

 

In court papers, the plaintiffs contended that Apple "has provided and continues to provide digital downloading of recordings of compositions which Eight Mile and Martin are owners of, or have copyright ownership interest in," without obtaining permission or providing compensation.

In contrast, the defendants have said there was authorization for the downloads and that Eminem's publisher has received "substantial royalties" on the songs.

The plaintiffs expect the trial to last five to seven days. It is not clear whether Eminem would testify, but he is not on the plaintiffs' witness list.

 

COPYRIGHT: (c) Reuters 2009. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by caching, framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters and the Reuters sphere logo are registered trademarks and trademarks of the Reuters group of companies around the world.

Up for Discussion

Connect with

More Features

All features

All of Billboard.com's Great Lists

Billboard chart app

Billboard archives

Thanks For Joining Billboard

Log in to create your profile, speak your mind and connect with listeners like you.

Why Join ?

Don't just hear it. Live it. Go deeper than a casual listen: Voice your feelings, build a profile around your favorite music, connect with people who share your passions and discover new ones. Sign up for free.

Complete Your Registration at Billboard.com!

Haven't Joined Yet ?

For the full Billboard experience, you need to be a member. Sign up. It's free.

Join Billboard

Forgot your password?

Enter the e-mail address you used to sign up and we will email you the password .

Email Sent !

Your password has been sent to the email address you provided. Please sign in below :

Log In

Forget your password ?

Action Successful

We'd love to hear your feedback on the new Billboard.com!

Whether it's a feature request or a bug

We want to hear from you. Please use this form to anonymously give us your input.