Billboard requires a JavaScript enabled browser to get the full experience

'American Idol' Stays Positive at Pittsburgh Auditions

by Kevin Rutherford  |   January 20, 2012 11:20 EST
Reed Grimm struts his stuff. Michael Becker/FOX

Artists in this Article

Gloria Gaynor
The Jackson 5
Steven Tyler
Jennifer Lopez
Justin Timberlake
Justin Bieber

Related Articles

'American Idol' Season 10: Where Are They Now?

In anticipation of this week's "American Idol" premiere (Wednesday, Jan. 18, 8 p.m. EST, FOX), we're taking a look at the contestants from "Idol" season 10 to see where, if anywhere, they have gone after their tenure on the show.

Will 'Idol' and 'The Voice' Ever Produce New Pop Stars?

Anyone wondering if singing competitions will produce pop stars again, consider some recently observed behind-the-scenes activity. It makes you wonder: Are singing competitions grooming too many Steve Perrys and not enough Katy Perrys?

'American Idol' Premiere: The Good, The Bad, The Strange of Savannah Auditions

To recap the first night of "Idol," we sound off on some of the most memorable auditions from Savannah -- the good, the bad and the downright puzzling.

'American Idol' Premiere Ratings Drop Double Digits

Not unexpectedly, "American Idol" dipped significantly with its Season 11 premiere.

Following up Wednesday's two-hour premiere in Savannah, "American Idol" rolled into Pittsburgh last night for, surprisingly, the first time in the show's history. The first in a series of one-hour audition episodes, Thursday night's "Idol" yielded chiefly great, or at least moderately good, singers. Keeping in line with the show's goal (as of last season, at least) of becoming a nurturing environment, only one performer whose audition was shown did not move on to the Hollywood round.

 

'American Idol' Premiere: The Good, The Bad, The Strange of Savannah Auditions

 

And so, we'll be sounding off on the best performances of the night (in no particular order). Which of the contestants had the best auditions, and which seem most likely to make "Idol"'s hallowed Top 24? Read on to find out.

 

Hee Jun Han

 


Hands up -- who saw this one coming? Hee Jun sure didn't. The Korean-born contestant seemed disconnected leading up to his performance, but surprised even the judges with a pitch-perfect rendition of "How Am I Supposed to Live Without You." "I am really impressed and shocked," said Randy, while Steven mused that Hee Jun "could be an American Idol" -- at which point it was the 22-year-old's turn to be stupefied. Not bad for a guy whose own family didn't even know he could sing.

 

Eben Franckewitz

 


Remember last night, when we compared David "Mr. Steal Your Girl" Leathers to Justin Bieber? Meet the Biebz's true doppelganger. The 15-year-old Eben Franckewitz has been practicing for the "Idol" stage practically his entire life, and possesses a very natural soprano that impressed the judges enough to earn him a ticket to Hollywood. Both the upside and downside to Eben is that he has a lot of potential, meaning that his voice isn't fully seasoned yet. So if he doesn't stay long, don't fret -- he'll be fine.

 

Reed Grimm

 


Reed is this season's definition of "effortless" thus far. A performer who began singing at the age of two and performed with his family band, the 26-year-old nanny may be Season 11's answer to Casey Abrams -- he even has the "air upright bass" down, or so it seems. In what is undoubtedly a first for the show, he performed a jazzy version of the "Family Matters" theme (seriously), and earned a resounding yes from the judges. Look for the Wisconsin native to slide effortlessly through this competition.

 

Hallie Day

 


It's funny how certain song choices can have a deeper emotional effect depending on the singer. If it seemed like the 24-year-old Hallie sang Gloria Gaynor's "I Will Survive" with powerful conviction, it may be due to her back story. The Baltimore native had hit rock bottom years before, nearly taking her own life. But with the help of her husband, Hallie survived, and now moving forward to Hollywood.

 

Creighton Fraker

 


The New Yorker sounded like a Justin Timberlake impersonator at first, even capping off his initial song choice -- an original tune -- with a bona fide Justin impression. But Creighton stunned the judges on his performance of The Jackson 5's "Who's Loving You," exhibiting a "wild and crazy" vocal style  that is undoubtedly unique for the competition. Sure, they're impressed -- but will "Idol" fans also fall in love with his off-kilter voice should he make it to the voting rounds?

 

Also worth checking out: the return of tenth season contestant Travis Orlando, mobile DJ Erika Van Pelt's endearing rendition of Carole King, Samantha Novacek and her amazing planking sister.

 

What did you think of last night's episode? Do you like the new direction the show is going in with its televised auditions? Let us know, and remember that there's a special night of "Idol" this Sunday, January 22, after the NFL's NFC Championship Game.

Up for Discussion

Connect with

More Features

All features

All of Billboard.com's Great Lists

Billboard chart app

Billboard archives

Thanks For Joining Billboard

Log in to create your profile, speak your mind and connect with listeners like you.

Why Join ?

Don't just hear it. Live it. Go deeper than a casual listen: Voice your feelings, build a profile around your favorite music, connect with people who share your passions and discover new ones. Sign up for free.

Complete Your Registration at Billboard.com!

Haven't Joined Yet ?

For the full Billboard experience, you need to be a member. Sign up. It's free.

Join Billboard

Forgot your password?

Enter the e-mail address you used to sign up and we will email you the password .

Email Sent !

Your password has been sent to the email address you provided. Please sign in below :

Log In

Forget your password ?

Action Successful

We'd love to hear your feedback on the new Billboard.com!

Whether it's a feature request or a bug

We want to hear from you. Please use this form to anonymously give us your input.