Billboard requires a JavaScript enabled browser to get the full experience

'American Idol' Judges Were Too Harsh, Say Ousted Contestants

Comments

by Gary Graff, Detroit  |   February 26, 2010 6:08 EST
FOX
Tyler Grady performs on
Fox

Back to Idol HQ

Related Articles

'American Idol' Recap: Crystal Bowersox Shines

Billboard's Ann Donahue breaks down every live performance of "American Idol" Season 9, from the top 24 contestants to the last one standing.

'American Idol' Recap: Michael Lynche Can't Salvage Sub-Par Night

Billboard's Ann Donahue breaks down every live performance of "American Idol" Season 9, from the top 24 contestants to the last one standing.

'American Idol' Eliminates Tyler Grady, Ashley Rodriguez, Janell Wheeler, Joe Munoz

"American Idol" voters said goodbye to the first four contestants of season nine on Thursday night, eliminating Janell Wheeler, Joe Munoz, Ashley Rodriguez and Tyler Grady.

Shortly after being ousted from "American Idol's" class of 2010, the four eliminated contestants still sounded a bit shell-shocked from a particularly harsh round of judges' comments.

 

'American Idol' Elminates First Four Contestants

 

"Yeah, they were not taking any chances this week," Ashley Rodriguez said during a conference call with reporters the day after the first results show. "I think a lot of people thought maybe they'd be a little lenient considering it was our first live show. Turns out they were coming throwing punches. There was definitely no leniency with it being our first live show, which is unfortunate 'cause there are a lot of jitters and nerves that go into a first live performance. We definitely could've used a little bit of love from them, for sure; I think they were very quick to give a lot of criticism and not back it up with anything positive, which is unfortunate."

 

'American Idol' Recap: Crystal Bowersox Shines

 

Janell Wheeler agreed that performing for the first time on the live "American Idol" stage was an adjustment for all 24 of the contestants. "Being there is so different. Being live, the band is really, really loud and aggressive and awesome, and you get so into it...We don't know how the sound works yet." But Wheeler also predicted that for the remaining contestants, "it's gonna get better and better. Each time they get on the stage and used to what it sounds like, it's gonna get better. It was difficult to grasp that at first."

 

Classic rocker Tyler Grady, meanwhile, was concerned that his strong response to the judges' seemingly contradictory comments about his '70s-styled look and approach would be misconstrued by viewers. "I meant no disrespect by that," he explained. "When you're a contestant in that situation and you're getting conflicting views, it's very confusing. I don't blame the judges at all; when I made that comment I was simply expressing my feelings at the time. I felt as a contestant on the show you need to stand up for yourself and go out wtih some dignity."

 

'American Idol' Recap: Michael Lynche Can't Salvage Sub-Par Night

 

All four of the now ex-Idols vowed that America would hear more from them again, and all four predicted they'd be recording albums in the near future. Joe Munoz added that "there's a lot of artists doing a lot of things right now. I really want to be that kind of artist -- being in musical theater, on TV and make records for people." Wheeler predicted that after decompressing at home in Tampa, "hopefully I'm Nashville-bound," and Grady said he's motivated to push harder with his Pennsylvania-based band Wailing Waters.

 

Up for Discussion

Jump to Forums

Sort By

Page:

Connect with

More Features

All features

Listy

Billboard chart app

Billboard archives

Thanks For Joining Billboard

Log in to create your profile, speak your mind and connect with listeners like you.

Why Join ?

Don't just hear it. Live it. Go deeper than a casual listen: Voice your feelings, build a profile around your favorite music, connect with people who share your passions and discover new ones. Sign up for free.

Complete Your Registration at Billboard.com!

Haven't Joined Yet ?

For the full Billboard experience, you need to be a member. Sign up. It's free.

Join Billboard

Forgot your password?

Enter the e-mail address you used to sign up and we will email you the password .

Email Sent !

Your password has been sent to the email address you provided. Please sign in below :

Log In

Forget your password ?

Action Successful

We'd love to hear your feedback on the new Billboard.com!

Whether it's a feature request or a bug

We want to hear from you. Please use this form to anonymously give us your input.