Billboard requires a JavaScript enabled browser to get the full experience
Column Header

Yaaawn: 'Idol' Underwhelms in San Diego - Plus Jim Carrey's Daughter Auditions

Michael Becker/FOX

Artists in this Article

Creedence Clearwater Revival
Monica
Steven Tyler
Jennifer Lopez

Related Articles

'American Idol' Season 10: Where Are They Now?

In anticipation of this week's "American Idol" premiere (Wednesday, Jan. 18, 8 p.m. EST, FOX), we're taking a look at the contestants from "Idol" season 10 to see where, if anywhere, they have gone after their tenure on the show.

Will 'Idol' and 'The Voice' Ever Produce New Pop Stars?

Anyone wondering if singing competitions will produce pop stars again, consider some recently observed behind-the-scenes activity. It makes you wonder: Are singing competitions grooming too many Steve Perrys and not enough Katy Perrys?

'American Idol' Premiere: The Good, The Bad, The Strange of Savannah Auditions

To recap the first night of "Idol," we sound off on some of the most memorable auditions from Savannah -- the good, the bad and the downright puzzling.

'American Idol' Premiere Ratings Drop Double Digits

Not unexpectedly, "American Idol" dipped significantly with its Season 11 premiere.

'American Idol' Stays Positive at Pittsburgh Auditions

"American Idol" rolled into Pittsburgh last night for, surprisingly, the first time in the show's history. The first in a series of one-hour audition episodes, Thursday night's "Idol" yielded chiefly great, or at least moderately good, singers.

Miss the third audition round of "American Idol" Sunday night after the NFL's NFC Championship Game went into overtime? It's OK. You didn't miss much of anything.

 

In what was one of the most lackluster "Idol" episodes ever, Randy, Jennifer and Steven traveled to San Diego to see what the lower west coast had to offer. To even say that any of the performances stood out from each other would be a stretch. What's more: during the episode, only eight full auditions were shown at all. And as with the second night of auditions, only one of those was footage of a rejected contestant.

 

With this abundance of bland positivity, it's no wonder the show's ratings are dropping. Hollywood week can't come soon enough.

 

Still, I have a job to do. So in no particular, here are the five auditions worth mentioning from last night. Just remember: I may have to eat crow come February from this statement, but don't expect any of the below to be with us come the Top 24.

 

Aubree Dieckmeyer

 


After determining what show she was auditioning for ("America's Next Top Model"? Really? Please tell me that was the producers' idea), young Aubree serenaded the judges with her rendition of jazz standard "Feeling Good." She's cute and her voice is sweet, but will she last a second in Hollywood week with such a thin higher register? I'm not so sure just yet. Still, she's probably the most intriguing of last night's hopefuls, and that counts for something... right?

 

Jane Carrey

 


The 24-year-old waitress/mom has been living under her father's shadow since she was born, and sees "Idol" as a way to establish herself as something in this world. That can be tough when your dad is Jim Carrey. After auditioning with "Something to Talk About," the judges were full of constructive criticism, but all in all liked her pretty little voice and sent her through. But make no mistake -- Jane's audition was likely only shown due to her father's star power. She's good, but don't expect to see her for long.

 

Kyle Crews

 


The 19-year-old UC Berkeley frat boy wowed the judges and impressed Steven enough to 1.) call him the "best male voice we've heard yet, and 2.) remind him of himself. Whaaa? OK, Kyle's performance of Monica's "Angel of Mine" was definitely very good, and I certainly didn't expect that sort of voice to come from his mouth, but best male voice? I'm guessing Steven was talking about the San Diego auditions. Hoping, too. Good voice, but that's some high praise, Mr. Tyler.

 

Jason "Wolf" Hamlin

 


Ah, the male rock singer! Here's something we haven't seen enough of so far this season. Jason, who goes by the nickname of Wolf (it's even printed on his work shirt), began his audition with Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Midnight Special," but it was the scruffy-faced golf course mechanic's impassioned rendition of "Folsom Prison Blues" that sealed the deal. If Wolf can howl over his "git-fiddle" (a homemade guitar) in Hollywood, he just might have a shot. Otherwise? Forget about him.

 

Ashley Robles

 


Let's call Ashley the dark horse of this group. The 26-year-old may not get remembered much beyond today, but her rendition of "I Will Always Love You" is certainly worthy of the judges' praise -- "Where you been all this time?!" exclaims Randy. However, while her turn on the chorus is powerhouse material, her lower register pales in comparison. Still, she has the voice to potentially go far, but she brings to memory one Pia Toscano -- a ballad singer who eventually became too predictable.

 

Also-rans: The quirky Ali Shields and her Natasha Bedingfield-esque voice, the smooth R&B (but limited range) of Jayrah Gibson.

 

Did you stay up to watch last night's delayed episode of "Idol"? Were you as underwhelmed as we were? Let us know in the comments, and tune in Wednesday at 8 p.m. for the next installment of auditions.

Up for Discussion

Connect with

More Features

All features

All of Billboard.com's Great Lists

Billboard chart app

Billboard archives

Thanks For Joining Billboard

Log in to create your profile, speak your mind and connect with listeners like you.

Why Join ?

Don't just hear it. Live it. Go deeper than a casual listen: Voice your feelings, build a profile around your favorite music, connect with people who share your passions and discover new ones. Sign up for free.

Complete Your Registration at Billboard.com!

Haven't Joined Yet ?

For the full Billboard experience, you need to be a member. Sign up. It's free.

Join Billboard

Forgot your password?

Enter the e-mail address you used to sign up and we will email you the password .

Email Sent !

Your password has been sent to the email address you provided. Please sign in below :

Log In

Forget your password ?

Action Successful

We'd love to hear your feedback on the new Billboard.com!

Whether it's a feature request or a bug

We want to hear from you. Please use this form to anonymously give us your input.