With such addictive, ultra-hooky gems as the swaying "City Girl" and the amped-up "Under Water," this Canadian sibling duo fully delivers here on the promise of its U.S.

With such addictive, ultra-hooky gems as the swaying "City Girl" and the amped-up "Under Water," this Canadian sibling duo fully delivers here on the promise of its U.S. debut, 2000's This Business of Art. Actually, the group does more than deliver; studio-slick in all the right ways and uncommonly strong throughout ("Don't Confess," the set's last song, is one of its best), If It Was You is a near pop-rock masterpiece. These perfectly performed and captured cuts are masterfully spiced with a handclap here, a surprising and subtle banjo there, and sweet backing vocals all over the place—proving that the Vancouver-based Quinn sisters and producers John Collins and David Carswell have priceless pop sensibilities. Part of what makes If It Was You so irresistible is that Tegan & Sara deliver mature songs while not losing a tad of their youthful energy—and occasionally flashing a bit of angst. While seeming to have fully developed their own voice, the Quinn sisters have clearly given us one of the best albums of the year.—WO

Questions? Comments? Let us know: @billboard

Print