Billboard.com readers got it wrong. Of 2,004 voters, 37% chose Chris Daughtry to win this season's "American Idol" in the same week the aspiring singer was voted off of the show.

Billboard.com readers got it wrong. Of 2,004 voters, 37% chose Chris Daughtry to win this season's "American Idol" in the same week the aspiring singer was voted off of the show.

Taylor Hicks came in second with 30%, followed by Catherine McPhee (23%) and Elliot Yamin (10%). Of course, these singers are still in the competition.

So, try again, folks… the poll's up again with the remaining three.