For the first time in "American Idol" history, the top five of the show is all one gender -- in this case, female. After making it to the top six despite poor reviews by judges, Lazaro Arbos received the lowest number of votes Thursday night (April 11), forcing the 22-year-old Florida native to sing for the judges' save. Despite an adequate "Feeling Good," weeks of negative comments meant the judges weren't having it. "You've been a treasure to the show," Randy Jackson said, "but we're not going to use the save."